Paris: Top 50 Shopping & Fashion Travel Instagram Influencers

As of September 2026, infloo tracks 236 Instagram creators in Paris in the Shopping & Fashion Travel category. Among the 50 largest by followers, the median engagement rate is 0.17% (middle half: 0.07–1.23%), and the median account has 5.2M followers. Over 1M followers: 50 of 50. Highest engagement: @beccca (14.72%), @xkarentorresx (11.26%), @yezyizhere (8.26%).

Creators tracked: 236
Median ER (top 50): 0.17%
Middle half of ER (top 50): 0.07–1.23%
Median followers (top 50): 5.2M
Data as of: September 2026

#	Instagram Account	Categories	Number of followers	Audience Engagement (ER)	User's Country	User's City	Check Fake Followers
1	1 CHANEL @chanelofficial Followers: 59,791,224 • ER: 0.04% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Vintage Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Vintage Fashion	Followers 59,791,224	ER 0.04%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
2	2 Dior Official @dior Followers: 46,749,387 • ER: 0.04% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 46,749,387	ER 0.04%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
3	3 Lily Collins @lilyjcollins Followers: 28,847,263 • ER: 1.65% Paris Movies & TV Shows Actors or Actress Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Movies & TV Shows Actors or Actress Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends	Followers 28,847,263	ER 1.65%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
4	4 숮이 💙🎧🐟🦭❄️⛄️💎🧊✈️🚿🧸🩵🔂 @skuukzky Followers: 21,141,724 • ER: 3.91% Paris Movies & TV Shows Entertainment Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Fashion Trends Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Movies & TV Shows Entertainment Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Fashion Trends	Followers 21,141,724	ER 3.91%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
5	5 ELIE SAAB @eliesaabworld Followers: 18,136,544 • ER: 0.01% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 18,136,544	ER 0.01%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
6	6 Balqees @balqeesfathi Followers: 15,821,040 • ER: 0.04% Paris Theater Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Beauty Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Theater Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Beauty	Followers 15,821,040	ER 0.04%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
7	7 Hermès @hermes Followers: 15,279,437 • ER: 0.04% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Accessories Vintage Fashion Collectibles Vintage & Antique Decoration Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Accessories Vintage Fashion Collectibles Vintage & Antique Decoration	Followers 15,279,437	ER 0.04%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
8	8 Pia Jauncey @piajauncey Followers: 14,600,237 • ER: 0.22% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Fashion Trends Volleyball Activewear Modelling Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Fashion Trends Volleyball Activewear Modelling	Followers 14,600,237	ER 0.22%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
9	9 BRUNA BIANCARDI @brunabiancardi Followers: 14,057,774 • ER: 4.95% Paris Romantic Relation... Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Travel Agencies Travel Swimwear Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Romantic Relation... Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Travel Agencies Travel Swimwear	Followers 14,057,774	ER 4.95%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
10	10 Vogue France @voguefrance Followers: 10,653,822 • ER: 0.1% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes	Followers 10,653,822	ER 0.1%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
11	11 Olivier Rousteing @olivier_rousteing Followers: 9,797,664 • ER: 0.1% Paris Theater Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Theater Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends	Followers 9,797,664	ER 0.1%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
12	12 ZUHAIR MURAD @zuhairmuradofficial Followers: 9,578,478 • ER: 0.14% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 9,578,478	ER 0.14%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
13	13 Nabilla Vergara @nabilla Followers: 9,558,451 • ER: 1.23% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends	Followers 9,558,451	ER 1.23%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
14	14 Off-White™ @off____white Followers: 9,539,856 • ER: 0.03% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Streetwear Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Streetwear	Followers 9,539,856	ER 0.03%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
15	15 Lacoste @lacoste Followers: 8,469,329 • ER: 0.09% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Outdoor Wear Shoes Streetwear Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Outdoor Wear Shoes Streetwear	Followers 8,469,329	ER 0.09%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
16	16 Pull&Bear @pullandbear Followers: 7,784,347 • ER: 0.02% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes	Followers 7,784,347	ER 0.02%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
17	17 CELINE @celine Followers: 7,546,592 • ER: 0.09% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Luxury Cars Outdoor Wear Streetwear Vintage Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Luxury Cars Outdoor Wear Streetwear Vintage Fashion	Followers 7,546,592	ER 0.09%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
18	18 Negin Mirsalehi @negin_mirsalehi Followers: 7,168,624 • ER: 1.13% Paris Romantic Relation... Love & Intimacy Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Swimwear Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Romantic Relation... Love & Intimacy Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Swimwear	Followers 7,168,624	ER 1.13%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
19	19 Thylane-Lena rose @thylaneblondeau Followers: 6,872,300 • ER: 0.13% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 6,872,300	ER 0.13%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
20	20 JACQUEMUS @jacquemus Followers: 6,812,077 • ER: 1.21% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Formal Wear Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Formal Wear	Followers 6,812,077	ER 1.21%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
21	21 KARL LAGERFELD @karllagerfeld Followers: 6,677,848 • ER: 0.04% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes	Followers 6,677,848	ER 0.04%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
22	22 Melisa Aslı Yazıcı @melisapamuk Followers: 6,012,744 • ER: 6.86% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Beauty Tips & Hacks Beauty Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Beauty Tips & Hacks Beauty	Followers 6,012,744	ER 6.86%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
23	23 Sézane @sezane Followers: 5,630,254 • ER: 0.06% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Shoes Accessories Vintage Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Shoes Accessories Vintage Fashion	Followers 5,630,254	ER 0.06%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
24	24 YEJI @yezyizhere Followers: 5,426,412 • ER: 8.26% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Beauty Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Beauty	Followers 5,426,412	ER 8.26%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
25	25 Jean Paul Gaultier @jeanpaulgaultier Followers: 5,336,516 • ER: 0.01% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 5,336,516	ER 0.01%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
26	26 Camilla Luddington @camillaluddington Followers: 5,006,843 • ER: 0.51% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Formal Wear Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Formal Wear	Followers 5,006,843	ER 0.51%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
27	27 Vivienne Westwood @viviennewestwood Followers: 4,564,985 • ER: 0.2% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes	Followers 4,564,985	ER 0.2%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
28	28 Rebecca Patricia Armstrong @beccca Followers: 4,313,005 • ER: 14.72% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 4,313,005	ER 14.72%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
29	29 Jwana Karim @jwanagram Followers: 3,847,355 • ER: 0.1% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Travel Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Travel	Followers 3,847,355	ER 0.1%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
30	30 ROCK @anokyai Followers: 3,663,140 • ER: 4.72% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Beauty Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Beauty	Followers 3,663,140	ER 4.72%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
31	31 nesrin cavadzade @nesrin.cavadzade Followers: 3,479,343 • ER: 2.13% Paris Romantic Relation... Love & Intimacy Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Romantic Relation... Love & Intimacy Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends	Followers 3,479,343	ER 2.13%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
32	32 Giambattista Valli Paris @giambattistavalliparis Followers: 3,253,505 • ER: 0.02% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes	Followers 3,253,505	ER 0.02%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
33	33 Karen Torres @xkarentorresx Followers: 3,237,349 • ER: 11.26% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 3,237,349	ER 11.26%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
34	34 ISABEL MARANT @isabelmarant Followers: 3,142,085 • ER: 0.15% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 3,142,085	ER 0.15%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
35	35 Rebecca mahra rabhi مهرة ربيكا رابحي @divarebeccaofficiel Followers: 3,057,832 • ER: 0.96% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 3,057,832	ER 0.96%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
36	36 Alyssa Daguisé Ghazali @alyssadaguise Followers: 2,894,926 • ER: 4.39% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,894,926	ER 4.39%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
37	37 Carine Roitfeld @carineroitfeld Followers: 2,868,696 • ER: 0.13% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,868,696	ER 0.13%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
38	38 Lena Perminova @lenaperminova Followers: 2,765,161 • ER: 1.23% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Children Wear Lingerie & Intimates Maternity Fashion Baby Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Kids Fashion Children Wear Lingerie & Intimates Maternity Fashion Baby Fashion	Followers 2,765,161	ER 1.23%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
39	39 Ralph & Russo @ralphandrusso Followers: 2,715,698 • ER: 0.39% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,715,698	ER 0.39%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
40	40 ARIEL @makeupbyariel Followers: 2,679,735 • ER: 1.15% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Adult Modelling Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Adult Modelling Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,679,735	ER 1.15%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
41	41 Claudia Schiffer @claudiaschiffer Followers: 2,519,967 • ER: 0.86% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,519,967	ER 0.86%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
42	42 Kristina Bazan @kristinabazan Followers: 2,431,661 • ER: 0.08% Paris Theater Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Pop Art Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Theater Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Pop Art Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends	Followers 2,431,661	ER 0.08%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
43	43 KELLY PIQUET @kellypiquet Followers: 2,154,784 • ER: 5.59% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Fashion Kids Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,154,784	ER 5.59%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
44	44 Paris France 🇫🇷 Travel \| Hotels \| Food \| Tips @paris.explore Followers: 2,108,985 • ER: 0.16% Paris Cultural & Histor... Shopping & Fashio... Travel Agencies Travel Relocation Hotels Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Cultural & Histor... Shopping & Fashio... Travel Agencies Travel Relocation Hotels	Followers 2,108,985	ER 0.16%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
45	45 GEORGES HOBEIKA @georgeshobeika Followers: 2,000,088 • ER: 0.18% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Lingerie & Intimates Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 2,000,088	ER 0.18%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
46	46 Rabanne @rabanne Followers: 1,855,335 • ER: 0.06% Paris Theater Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Vintage Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Theater Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Vintage Fashion	Followers 1,855,335	ER 0.06%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
47	47 Stephen Hung @stephenhungofficial Followers: 1,831,571 • ER: 0.89% Paris Romantic Relation... Shopping & Fashio... Political Leaders Travel Agencies Travel Relocation Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Romantic Relation... Shopping & Fashio... Political Leaders Travel Agencies Travel Relocation	Followers 1,831,571	ER 0.89%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
48	48 ALAÏA @maisonalaia Followers: 1,830,653 • ER: 0.09% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Vintage Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Vintage Fashion	Followers 1,830,653	ER 0.09%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
49	49 The Frankie Shop @thefrankieshop Followers: 1,806,848 • ER: 0.02% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Shoes	Followers 1,806,848	ER 0.02%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts
50	50 Alexandra Lapp @alexandralapp Followers: 1,797,137 • ER: 0.36% Paris Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Kids Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion Check Fake Followers Get contacts	Shopping & Fashio... Luxury Fashion Fashion Kids Fashion Fashion Trends Women's Fashion	Followers 1,797,137	ER 0.36%	Country	City Paris	Check Fake Followers Get contacts

See the TikTok top Average Instagram engagement rate in France Check any Instagram creator for fake followers — free How we build the rankings and measure creators

Frequently asked questions

Who are the top Shopping & Fashion Travel Instagram influencers in Paris?

By followers: @chanelofficial (59.8M), @dior (46.7M), @lilyjcollins (28.8M). By engagement rate: @beccca (14.72%), @xkarentorresx (11.26%), @yezyizhere (8.26%). Data: infloo, September 2026.

What is a typical engagement rate for Shopping & Fashion Travel influencers in Paris?

The median is 0.17%; half of the 50 largest creators by followers fall between 0.07% and 1.23%. Data: infloo, September 2026.

How many Shopping & Fashion Travel Instagram influencers does infloo track in Paris?

236 as of September 2026. The ranking shows 50 of them, sorted by followers.

Our blog

Discover new things about Marketing, Trends and another priceless information

Which Influencer Discovery Plan Does Your Agency Need? 11 Questions About Limits, Exports and Cost

Five tiers meter four separate counters—searches, profile views, exports and data updates—at different ceilings. The plan that fits your agency is decided by whichever counter your workflow burns fastest, not by the feature list.

Engagement Rate, Views per Follower or Follower Count — Which Metric Should You Screen Influencers On?

Each of the three headline metrics answers a different question, and each breaks in a different place. Learn which one to lead with for reach buys, response-led campaigns, and multi-market comparisons.

How Do You Find and Vet Instagram Influencers in Brazil? A Stage-by-Stage Guide

Brazil's 50 largest Instagram accounts median 0.29% engagement—11th of 14 countries sampled. Platform choice is the largest lever: Brazil's biggest TikTok accounts median 8.98%, roughly 31x higher. Here's how to build a shortlist that survives review.